• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Pezzi Pizza

Pezzi Pizza is a local Italian pizza joint in Sea Cliff, NY, known for its crispy bottom crust and delicious specialty pizzas. Customers rave about the buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken varieties, praising the non-greasy and consistently well-done crust. The friendly and efficient staff, led by Calogero, ensures that orders are always accurate and ready on time. While the food always impresses with its flavors, some customers have noted occasional service mishaps, suggesting the need for better staffing. Overall, Pezzi Pizza remains a go-to spot for satisfying Italian cuisine, perfect for a casual dining experience or quick takeout.

LOCATIONS

Pezzi Pizza, located in Sea Cliff, NY, is a local favorite when it comes to delicious Italian pizza. From their specialty pizzas like buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken to their crispy bottom crust pies, Pezzi Pizza offers a variety of options that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

With many vegetarian choices available, Pezzi Pizza caters to all dietary preferences. The restaurant is known for its efficient and friendly staff, ensuring that your dining experience is enjoyable whether you choose to dine in, take out, or opt for delivery.

One standout feature of Pezzi Pizza is its commitment to customer service and attention to detail. While some customers may have experienced minor hiccups with their orders, the overall consensus is that the food is consistently delicious and well-prepared.

Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice, hosting a gathering with friends, or looking for catering options, Pezzi Pizza has you covered. With convenient amenities like free Wi-Fi, outdoor seating, and a drive-thru option, Pezzi Pizza strives to provide a seamless dining experience for all guests.

Next time you're in the area and craving authentic Italian flavors, be sure to visit Pezzi Pizza for a taste of their mouth-watering pies and friendly atmosphere.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Pezzi Pizza
Chris L.
Chris L.

Speciality pizza is always delicious especially buffalo chicken and bbq chicken covered in chicken.

Jennifer N.
Jennifer N.

A good slice or pie if you like a crispy bottom crust. Everywhere else I would have to order "well done" to get what is consistently served here. Never greasy.

Darlyn D.
Darlyn D.

Food is amazing. Great specials. Efficient cordial staff. Eat in or take out it's the best!!

Joseph L.
Joseph L.

I regularly order a variety of pizza and dinner dishes to pick up from Pezzi and they are always delicious, well-prepared, ready when they promise and the staff is attentive and efficient. Calogero always greets me and all guests with a smile and makes sure that the order is correct. I highly recommend Pezzi for all types of italian food!

Fritz L.
Fritz L.

Good pizza. Nice crust. I'm adding a few more words coz Welp doesn't think 4 words is is enough when it comes to pizza. That's one more than the ingredients. Dough, cheese, sauce.

Paul H.
Paul H.

I recently placed a catering order for a home dinner I was hosting on Saturday 12/17/22 with close some friends coming over the house. I ordered about 4 days in advance for me to pick up at 5:30 pm. I arrived at Pezzi Pizza at about 5:35 pm and noticed that it was crazy busy with just Calogero (one of the sons/owners) and an employee working in the front. The phone was ringing, customers were ordering and paying, and it was chaotic with limited staff. I paid cash (approximately $285) to avoid the credit card surcharge and the employee helped me to bring my order to me car. I felt grateful that my order was ready and to leave with my order. I was about 2 minutes from home when my phone rang in my car ... "Hi, it's Pezzi Pizza, we forgot to give you your Caesar salad because the kitchen was still making it when you picked up your food." I was not happy to hear this and told them that I'd drop my food off and return to Pezzi Pizza to pick up the Caesar salad. My guests had already arrived at my house and I had to explain to them that Pezzi Pizza forgot to give me the Caesar salad that I ordered. I needed to leave my party and return to Pezzi Pizza. When I entered I again saw Calogero and the worker very busy working. The worker handed me the salad tray and I told Calogero that I wasn't happy to have to return to the restaurant for the salad that they forgot to pack for me. He told me, "we're doing the best we can." There were two words I didn't hear from either Calogero or the employee ... and that is "I'm sorry." That would have gone a long way and also some accommodation like, "I'm sorry tonight for the inconvenience but we're short staffed. Please remind me when you come for dinner next time and I'll try to make it up to you (e.g., a complimentary glass or two of wine). I live 5 1/2 miles from Pezzi Pizza and it took me about 1/2 hour to return to Pezzi Pizza and return home with the Caesar salad. That means I missed 1/2 hour of my diner party. The food was great! It never disappoints but I need to take one star away from my original review because they forgot to pack my Caesar salad with the rest of my order and I truly believe they could have handled it better when I returned to the restaurant. I'm not in the restaurant industry, but as an observer, it seems to me that Pezzi Pizza needs to appropriately staff the restaurant so they can provide the customer service we should expect. 1/2 Tray Penne alla Vodka 1/2 Tray Chix Francese 1/2 Tray Chix Parm 1/2 Tray Broccoli & Oil 1/2 Tray Caesar salad

Peter O.
Peter O.

I was working and we needed to get something to eat. We were really hungry. We had our fill of deli food and one of my associates said pizza might be a good option. Right down the street across from North Shore HS is Pezzi Pizza. We called for a large pizza: half sausage and half extra cheese. We picked it up, but we could have them deliver at no charge. We sat down to eat and it was hot and delicious. I like thin crust and this was perfect for us. We enjoyed our pizza and we enjoyed each others company. When you smell food that smells great and its tastes great you know you have something special. Pezzi is a local favorite pizza restaurant and all the locals love it. The people are always happy to see you. The food is always hot and tastes great! Whenever, we have visitors who want good food and good serve at reasonable price, we highly recommend Pezzi Pizza. If you're in the area and you're hunger for Italian food, please stop in and have a great meal. Stay healthy and keep safe. Safe travels and enjoy life! All the best to you and your family.